El Cerrito residents are being asked to consider a $37 million investment in a new library facility. Supporters describe a modern, code-compliant building with updated technology, expanded programming, improved accessibility, community gathering space, and even emergency shelter capabilities. Those goals sound positive on paper. But before we commit tens of millions of dollars, we needContinue reading “$37 Million for Another Community Center?”
Category Archives: library
There’s No Guarantee the Library Gets Built — But the Tax Is Guaranteed
Understanding What’s Actually Being Proposed in El Cerrito In June, El Cerrito voters will be asked to decide on a parcel tax being marketed as a “library initiative.” The vote is on. But residents deserve to understand exactly what they are being asked to approve before casting a ballot. Right now, there is no publiclyContinue reading “There’s No Guarantee the Library Gets Built — But the Tax Is Guaranteed”
2026 Library Renovations: Contra Costa County Updates
influenced by concerned citizens’ comments Across Contra Costa County in 2026, fans of books and community space are facing temporary closures as multiple library branches undergo major renovations and infrastructure upgrades. These projects address long-deferred maintenance, including roofs, HVAC systems, electrical infrastructure, lighting, accessibility improvements, and air quality upgrades. Libraries Currently Undergoing Major Renovations AccordingContinue reading “2026 Library Renovations: Contra Costa County Updates”
When Questions Get Shut Down, It Tells You Something
On Saturday evening an El Cerrito resident posted a Vote Yes advertisement on NextDoor promoting the library tax. When community members began asking reasonable questions—about costs, long-term impacts, and accountability—the response wasn’t engagement. It was restriction. Comments were immediately closed. No further discussion was allowed. And prior comments were erased. The post stayed up. TheContinue reading “When Questions Get Shut Down, It Tells You Something”
From $157,000 to Nearly $800,000: Why Trust Is Fracturing in El Cerrito
Residents are not confused. They are reading. On page 24 of the City’s own impact report, the current library’s annual operating cost is listed at $157,615. On the same page, the report acknowledges that operating and maintenance costs could reach $797,000 annually for the El Cerrito Plaza library — a more than 400% increase. AgendaContinue reading “From $157,000 to Nearly $800,000: Why Trust Is Fracturing in El Cerrito”
El Cerrito’s 17¢ Story Doesn’t Add Up
EC Library: They’re Asking You to Pay $340/Year — But the Math Says $860 Influence by social media posts and comments For months, voters were told a simple, digestible number: 17 cents per square foot.A 2,000-square-foot home = $340 per year. It sounded responsible. But critical financial information was not disclosed. At the February 3rdContinue reading “El Cerrito’s 17¢ Story Doesn’t Add Up”
Is El Cerrito’s Library Tax Too Vague? Key Concerns
The City of El Cerrito has released its official Notice of Intention regarding a proposed library tax measure. At first glance, it reads like a standard statement of purpose. But when you look closer, several key discrepancies emerge—raising questions about transparency, scope, and what residents are truly being asked to support. The Notice Frames theContinue reading “Is El Cerrito’s Library Tax Too Vague? Key Concerns”
Why the City Manager Must Communicate Decisions Clearly
We don’t expect a city manager to answer every email. But we do expect her to lead — and that means explaining the why behind major decisions that affect the people she serves. When residents ask legitimate questions about the library project, bond funding, or use of reserves, they deserve clear answers — not silenceContinue reading “Why the City Manager Must Communicate Decisions Clearly”
El Cerrito’s Selective Spending: Expert Voices Without Expertise
From a recent social media discussion. At the October 7 City Council meeting, the Council considered authorizing an additional $391,000 to Ghirardelli Associates for “construction management services” related to the El Cerrito Del Norte Transit-Oriented Development Complete Streets Project. This wasn’t a competitive bid. It was a contract extension, justified by claims that the originalContinue reading “El Cerrito’s Selective Spending: Expert Voices Without Expertise”
El Cerrito’s Library Plan: Vague Before the Vote, Decided After
One of the most troubling patterns in El Cerrito’s governance is how little concrete information is shared before voters are asked to approve new taxes — only for detailed plans to surface after the initiative passes, when residents no longer have meaningful leverage. The proposed library tax measure is a prime example. Parking Details: Selective,Continue reading “El Cerrito’s Library Plan: Vague Before the Vote, Decided After”
El Cerrito Library Proposal: Who Really Benefits?
El Cerrito is moving ahead with plans to build a new library at Fairmount and Liberty, near the Plaza BART station. At first glance, the idea of a modern library sounds appealing—who doesn’t want better facilities for families, students, and lifelong learners? However, upon closer examination, serious disadvantages become apparent. This isn’t about opposing libraries.Continue reading “El Cerrito Library Proposal: Who Really Benefits?”
Libraries are good. This plan isn’t.
El Cerrito deserves a great library—but not at the wrong price. The City’s plan locks residents into $75M+ in new taxes for a ground-floor space in a BART housing project that the City won’t even own. We need a better plan—one that gives El Cerrito a true library, not just another forever tax. 👉 IfContinue reading “Libraries are good. This plan isn’t.”
Grasping at Straws
Proponents of the massive and costly library are grasping at straws. Some community members and leaders in El Cerrito argue that our city’s library is underused because it is “too old.” The implication is that if only we spent $75 million or more on a massive and costly new facility, people would suddenly flock backContinue reading “Grasping at Straws”
El Cerrito Library Tax: What It Really Means for Homeowners
El Cerrito is moving forward with plans to place a new library tax on the ballot. The city is trying to keep itself at arm’s length by having former Councilmember Greg Lyman be the face of the measure. But make no mistake—El Cerrito is behind the scenes, pulling the levers. At first glance, the costContinue reading “El Cerrito Library Tax: What It Really Means for Homeowners”
Library Plan Serves Developers, Not Residents
Across El Cerrito, the agents of the City are holding meetings to promote its so-called “Transit-Oriented Development Library” project. They’re also going door to door promoting this initiative. On the surface, it sounds like progress—finally replacing the undersized, aging library. But residents should look more closely at what’s being pitched. This is not a trueContinue reading “Library Plan Serves Developers, Not Residents”
A $75+ Million Gamble El Cerrito Can’t Afford
El Cerrito voters are being asked to consider a massive $75 million+ tax measure for a new library. But before agreeing to decades of new taxes, residents deserve to ask a simple question: what guarantee do we have that this library will ever get built? The city’s current plan relies on the construction of aContinue reading “A $75+ Million Gamble El Cerrito Can’t Afford”
Rethinking El Cerrito’s Library Expansion: A Community Approach
A recent East Bay Times article highlights the undeniable challenges facing El Cerrito’s public library: it’s overcrowded, outdated, and seismically unsafe. No one disputes that the current facility falls short of what the community deserves (see the full article here). But the article stops short of asking an equally important question—what’s the most responsible and sustainableContinue reading “Rethinking El Cerrito’s Library Expansion: A Community Approach”
A History of Broken Promises and Misplaced Priorities
Thank you to the neighbors and community members who continue raising essential questions about how our city spends taxpayer money. It’s not just about one issue—it’s about a decades-long pattern of financial decisions that don’t align with the promises made to voters. Remember Measure D? In 2008, El Cerrito voters approved a 30-year bond (MeasureContinue reading “A History of Broken Promises and Misplaced Priorities”
El Cerrito Library Campaign v3.1
The Committee for a Plaza Station Library wants your support—and your money. But before you sign their petition or vote to raise your taxes, here’s what you should know. According to their own campaign filing, the Committee spent $12,125.68 in the last quarter alone. That includes: $203.89 paid to John Stashik’s Premier Graphics for 500Continue reading “El Cerrito Library Campaign v3.1”
The Real Reason El Cerrito Isn’t Talking About Unrestricted Reserves Part II
Since FY22–23, El Cerrito’s unrestricted General Fund reserves have been in steady decline. And it’s no accident. Behind the scenes, the City has been quietly drawing down those reserves—while hoping the public won’t notice. Why? Because they’re counting on voters to approve the so-called “Forever Tax” to plug the holes. In 2023, the City CouncilContinue reading “The Real Reason El Cerrito Isn’t Talking About Unrestricted Reserves Part II”
El Cerrito Committee for Responsible Government (ECCRG) 